Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY
Dexknows® - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local DexKnows directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. DexKnows advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.
Visit Website
We’re a one stop destination for the freshest, locally and globally sourced sustainable seafood – to go, or to eat here. Shop our gourmet seafood Market, di
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards, discover, amex, master card, visa
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol
- Payment method:
- cash only, no credit cards
- Amenities:
- Has Wifi
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards
The story of SALT started with Keith and Ali's love for Shelter Island. SALT was designed as a come as you are restaurant with a focus on fresh and loc
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- amex, visa, cash, discover, master card
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards, amex, visa, cash, master card
- Amenities:
- Wheelchair accessible, Good for groups, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- amex, master card, visa, all major credit cards, cash, discover
- Amenities:
- Wheelchair accessible, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards, debit, visa, amex, discover, master card
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Good for groups, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards, visa, amex, discover, master card
Porto Bello features Northern Italian Style Fare with weekly specials that venture into more Contemporary American Dishes. Signature dishes of our Dinner me
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- discover, master card, all major credit cards, amex, visa
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- discover
- Amenities:
- Wheelchair accessible, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol
- Payment method:
- amex, discover, master card, visa, mastercard, all major credit cards
Come for the considered and approachable coastal American fare; linger for the convivial and vivacious atmosphere; stay for an unparalleled East E
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- discover, cash, master card, visa, amex, all major credit cards, debit
- Brands:
- None
Run by daughter-father team Valerie and Robert Mnuchin—and named after Valerie's paternal grandfather—Léon captures the romance of European adventures a
See why so many travelers make Sunset Beach their hotel of choice when visiting Shelter Island. Providing an ideal mix of value, comfort and convenience,
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Good for groups, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations, Good for families
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards, amex, master card, visa
Working waterfront revival on the half shell. Shuck your own oysters at one of the waterfront picnic tables. Shucking instruction and gear provided! Oysters
- Payment method:
- paypal, mastercard, visa, discover
Fresh and innovative menu. Outdoor dining, live music, creative tiki-style cocktai
- Payment method:
- amex, cash, discover, master card, visa
Your home away from home, Andy's serves up creative gastropub food in a casual setting. The best wings in town, build your own burger, and a fun kids' me
- Amenities:
- Wheelchair accessible
- Payment method:
- discover, master card, visa, all major credit cards
- Brands:
- fresh
Long Island's Premier Destination for Authentic Craft BBQ with a full bar & live Sports! Parties up to 10 and chilldren are welcome!Long Island's Premi
We are a French-owned & inspired brand with a fashion boutique on beautiful Shelter Island and GreenportWe are a French-owned & inspired brand with a fashi
- Amenities:
- Wheelchair accessible
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards
Terra is located at the Greenporter Hotel in the heart of Greenport, Long Island. It features a Coffee Bar open daily at 7am and a cocktail bar with sma
- Payment method:
- amex, cash, master card, visa
Opened in 2012, First and South is a relaxed atmosphere with quality fare, drinks, craft beer & wine! A well-rounded view of what the North Fork environme
- Amenities:
- Offers outdoor seating, Wheelchair accessible, Has Wifi, Serves alcohol, Takes reservations
- Payment method:
- all major credit cards, amex, visa, cash, discover, master card
Executive Chef Yvonne Contemporary Dockside Restaurant & Bar Fresh Pasta High-end Steaks Seafood Southold - North Fork, LIExecutive Chef Yvonne Contempora