Our third generation, family run insurance agency was started in 1960 by Grandfather Dennis McElhinny. Son Richard McElhinny started with the firm in 1973 and is a boat coverage specialist. Richard brought his sons Timothy McElhinny, CIC, LUTCF into the agency in 1988, and Thomas McElhinny, CIC, LUTCF in 1989. We currently employ 6 full-time licensed insurance agents and a life insurance specialist.
Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate

Reviews

RI
Rian I.

02/21/2015

Provided by YP.com

I recently had my first auto insurance claim and the McElhinny Insurance handled everything wonderfully. They answered all my questions and took the time to ease my mind. Thank You to the staff there, you have earned a customer for life.

RI
Rian I.

02/21/2015

Provided by Superpages

McElhinny Insurance has always taken great care of me. Their staff always take the time to answer my questions and help me understand my insurance coverage.

anonymous

07/23/2012

Provided by Superpages

I have been with McElhinny Insurance (Erie) for several years now. I did review rates with other companies last fall, and nobody could beat my current rate with them! They are also very personable, and (during business hours) there is always someone I can call directly, with no automated phone system (pushing 1, 2, 12, 32 until I can talk to a human). I have 2 cars and my homeowners with them, and wouldn't change a thing. Thanks!

D
dmb7204

01/21/2012

Provided by YP.com
I have been with McElhinny Ins...

Great Customer Service



I have been with McElhinny Insurance for 13 years; the customer service is excellent and the staff is very accomodating. I would recommend them to anyone.

claimed iconBusiness Response01/23/2012

McElhinny Insurance Agency wants to thank you for your business and the opportunity to provide your insurance. We are glad we can help. Tim McElhinny, CIC, LUTCF

This listing has been claimed by a business representative.
anonymous

06/01/2011

Provided by Superpages

I want to thank the McElhinny Insurance Agency for helping me with my auto insurance. They gave me a great rate, explained everything to me, and made switching companies very easy. I would recommend them if you are looking for a great insurance agency.

anonymous

06/01/2011

Provided by Superpages

I want to thank the McElhinny Insurance Agency for helping me with my auto insurance. They gave me a great rate, explained everything to me, and made switching companies very easy. I would recommend them if you are looking for a great insurance agency.

T
turboagent

01/17/2011

Provided by YP.com
Wonderful Local Pittsburgh Auto Insurance Agent!

McElhinny Insurance helped me with my auto insurance and answered all my questions in a way that I could understand. They were wonderful to work with and I highly recommend them.



Thank You!



Mark

T
turboagent

10/07/2010

Provided by YP.com
Very helpful and polite.

A very helpful and polite insurance agency. They took care of all my needs and answered all my questions. They are one of the best Pittsburgh area auto insurance agencies around.

anonymous

10/07/2010

Provided by Superpages

They were very helpful in answering all my questions about my auto insurance policy. I highly recommend them if shopping for auto insurance in Pittsburgh.

anonymous

04/13/2010

Provided by Superpages

Great insurance agency. Treated me like family. They are the best Pittsburgh auto insurance agency.

C
customer288

09/14/2009

Provided by YP.com
Satisfied Customer!

WOW what a joy dealing with McElhinny Insurance Agency. I was treated excellent and they answered all my questions without making me feel confused. I am happy they are my insurance agency!

B
bmh12

02/13/2009

Provided by Superpages

I've had 3 claims on 1 vehicle and all taken care of. 2 were from parked vandalization. 1 from a storm damage.

B
bmh12

02/13/2009

Provided by Superpages

I've had 3 claims on 1 vehicle and all taken care of. 2 were from parked vandalization. 1 from a storm damage.

P
pens2008

06/20/2008

Provided by YP.com
Excellent Service.

The McElhinny Insurance Agency was very professional and curtious. They answered my questions promptly and politely. I would purchase from them again and have recommended them to my family.

T
timmy275

04/24/2008

Provided by YP.com
Excellent Professionalism

The McElhinny Agency made me comfortable and explained the policy and limits in terms I could understand. I highly recommend them to anyone!

More Business Info

Family Protection from a 3rd Generation Family-Owned Agency

BBB Rating
A+
BBB Rating and Accreditation information may be delayed up to a week.
Hours
Regular Hours
Mon - Fri:
Sat - SunClosed
Services/Products
* Antique Cars Ins * ATV's & Motercycles Ins * Auto Ins * Auto,Home * Boat Ins * Boats * Business Ins * Classic Car Ins * Collectibles Ins * Contractors Ins * Fire Ins * Homeowner Ins * Individual Coverage * Jetski & Waverunners * Life Ins * Med Supplement Ins * Motorcycle Ins * Personal Water Craft * Pet Ins * Restaurant Ins * Recreational Vehicle * Rental Ins * Renters Ins * RV Ins * Seasonal Dwellings * Small Business * Snowmobile Ins * Specialty Autos & Collectible Autos
Brands
American Collectors, ERIE Insurance, Hagerty, Progressive
Payment method
amex, check, visa, mastercard
Location
Located on the border of Pleasant Hills and South Park
Neighborhood
Pleasant Hills
Accreditation

Pittsburgh Auto Insurance

Categories
Auto Insurance, Business & Commercial Insurance, Health Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Insurance, Life Insurance, Property & Casualty Insurance, Renters Insurance