Piece of Cake

Write a Review812-424-2253

OPEN NOW - Closes at 6:00pm

I have ordered my cakes from here for years. The last few times I have noticed the icing getting thicker and thicker. Today I got a beautiful cake for my sons 10th birthday shaped as a 10.....when I cut into the cake I find it had an inch and a half of icing on the outside of the cake. It was awful and embarrassing to serve. You pay $60 for a cake expect something you can serve.



Would you like some cake with your icing? Name should be Piece of Icing!



When I reached out to them to point out the issue I had with the cake they responded it happens to get the shape. So this wasn't a one time oopsie it is a standard.

If you have a baby at St. Mary's in Evansville they give you a free cake from Piece of Cake. It was wonderful. This is such a nice thing to do for new mothers and their families. It was great and I plan to order cakes from them in the future. Awesome!